Our Pies are Handmade from Scratch Using Only the Freshest Ingredients

At Lake Geneva Pie Company we put a lot of care into our fresh, handmade pies and other goodies. Enjoy our Old Fashioned Pies, whole or by the slice… dine here or carry out.

Locally sourced ingredients go into our season-fresh pies and other deserts. Carefully considered fillings made from nature’s ripe bounty and poured into hand-pinched crusts before the tempting treats are placed in our ovens. Then our near to bursting pies with golden brown crusts are placed on cooling racks until they are snatched up to be taken home or enjoyed on the spot.

Not all our pies or quiches are available are available every day. You may order any of our Pies, Cookies, Brownies, Muffins, Special Breads, Quiches, or Pot Pies for your special occasion or “Just Because” for no extra charge by calling ahead.

“We hand make ‘em so you can home bake ‘em”

Apple Crumb

Another customer favorite made with Northern Spy Apples that are baked in our special flaky crust and topped with a special crunchy topping.


Apple Pastry

apple pastry

Banana Cream

Loaded with Fresh Bananas and filled with our special recipe cream filling, topped with a non-dairy whipped topping.

banana cream

Berry Cherry Crumb

berry cherry 2

Blackberry Raspberry Pastry

Full-flavored delicious berries blended to perfection and baked in our freshly made flaky crust and topped with another crust to make it double delicious.


Blueberry Crumb

Plump, sumptuous blueberries baked in our signature flaky crust and topped with the same crunchy hand-tossed topping.


Blueberry Pastry

blueberry pastry

Cherry Crumb

Tart, juicy Montomorency Cherries baked in our freshly made flaky crust and topped with a crunchy hand-tossed topping.


Cherry Pastry

cherry pastry

Chocolate Cream

chocolate cream

Chocolate Pecan

chocolate pecan

Coconut Cream

coconut cream

Lakeshore Berry Crumb

A customer favorite is our tantalizing blend of strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and northern Spy Apples topped with our special crumb topping.

lakeshore berry crumb

Lemon Meringue

Tangy lemon pie with the perfect meringue topping…. Brown just right in a hot oven.

lemon meringue

Naturally Blueberry Pastry

naturally blueberry pastry

Peach Crumb

Mouth watering sweet peaches oven-baked and topped with a crunchy hand-tossed topping.


Peach Pastry

peach pastry

Pecan Pie

Gorgeous mixture of jumbo pecans, Karo Syrup, cane sugar, eggs and vanilla baked in our freshly make flaky crust that presents a shiny glossy top.


Pumpkin Pie

Memories of yesteryear and just like Grandma used to make with a  blend of the right amount of spices.


Pumple Pie

Apple Crumb + Pumpkin = Pumple


Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb

A special blend of rest strawberries and tart rhubarb baked in our freshly made signature crust and topped with a crunchy hand-tossed topping.


Fruit Pies

  • Adams Apple
  • Apple Rhubarb Crumb
  • Berry Cherry (rasp, cherry)
  • Berry Cherry Crumb (rasp, cherry)
  • Blackberry
  • Blackberry Apple Crumb
  • Blackberry Peach Crumb
  • Blueberry Apple Crumb
  • Blueberry Cobbler
  • Blueberry Peach Crumb
  • Cherry Apple Crumb
  • Cherry Rhubarb
  • Cherry Rhubarb Crumb
  • Cranberry
  • Cranberry Apple Crumb
  • Lakeshore Berry (rasp, black, straw, and apple)
  • Naturally Apple Pie (No Sugar Added)
  • Naturally Blueberry (No Sugar Added)
  • Naturally Cherry (No Sugar Added)
  • Naturally Lakeshore Berry (No Sugar Added)
  • Nick’s Garbage Crumb (7 Fruits No Apples)
  • Peach Apple Crumb
  • Peach Cobbler
  • Peach Strawberry
  • Peach Strawberry Crumb
  • Raspberry
  • Raspberry Apple Crumb
  • Raspberry Cranberry
  • Raspberry Peach
  • Rhubarb
  • Strawberry Rhubarb

Cream Pies & More

  • Baileys Chocolate Cream
  • Big Turtle (chocolate pecan with caramel)
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Chocolate Pecan
  • Creamy Peanut Butter French Silk
  • Coconut Cream
  • French Silk
  • Key Lime
  • Lemon Meringue
  • Peppermint Patti Silk

Other Goodies

    • Sugar Cookies
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies
    • Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
    • Peanut Butter Cookies
    • Chocolate Chip Brownies
    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars
    • Assorted Muffins
    • Assorted Snack Breads

Gluten Free

  • Muffins, Cookies, Pies & Quiches are available in Gluten Free.

*48 hours notice required for Gluten Free orders