Order Our Pies Today!

Call 262-248-5100 Today! Catering Available!

Order Online Now! Return To Shopping Checkout

About Us

Lake Geneva Pie Company has been serving “Wisconsinites” outstanding pies and goodies for over 15 years. We are a Wisconsin based company, established in November of 2001. We pride ourselves as a family owned and operated award winning bakery and cafe.

Enjoy our Old-Fashioned Pies, whole or by the slice… dine here or carry out. Not all of our pies or quiches are available every day. You may order any of our pies or quiches for your special occasions or “just because” for no extra charge by calling ahead.

Gift certificates are available. Use them as a gift of good taste for family and friends who want to enjoy the best pies in the Midwest. We also are very community orientated and donate over 100 of our wonderful pies per year to various local organizations to help raise awareness and funds.

IMG_0428

See what's cooking on Facebook