Lake Geneva Pie Company 

Pies

Our Pies are Handmade from Scratch Using Only the Freshest Ingredients
At Lake Geneva Pie Company we put a lot of care into our fresh, handmade pies and other goodies. Enjoy our Old Fashioned Pies, whole or by the slice… dine here or carry out.

Not all of our pies or quiches are available every day.

Locally sourced ingredients go into our season-fresh pies and other desserts. Carefully considered fillings made from nature’s ripe bounty and poured into hand-pinched crusts before the tempting treats are placed in our ovens. Then our near to bursting pies with golden brown crusts are placed on cooling racks until they are snatched up to be taken home or enjoyed on the spot.

9" Pies


Banana Cream
Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Key Lime
Pecan
Chocolate Pecan
Lemon Meringue

6" / 9" Fruit Pies


Cherry Crumb
Blueberry Crumb
Berry Cherry Crumb
Blueberry Peach Crumb
Peach Crumb
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb
Blackberry Peach Crumb
Garbage Crumb (available in 9" only)
Lakeshore Berry Crumb
Apple Crumb

6" / 9" Fruit Pastry Pies


Cherry Pie
Blueberry Pie
Cherry Rhubarb Pie
Blackberry Raspberry Pie
Peach Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Rhubarb Pie
Apple Pie
Lakeshore Berry Pie
Naturally Apple Pie

HOLIDAY PIES

Thanksgiving
Easter
Thanksgiving
Easter
Easter 2023 Pie Selection for pick up between 4/3 thru 4/8.
Call to place orders at 262-248-5100
No orders taken online--
 
The order cut off at Noon on 3/31 for the week of 4/3 thru 4/8
{GF} ** Also available to order in gluten-free form.
 
PIES 9” only
  • Cherry Crumb (GF)
  • Blueberry Crumb
  • Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb (GF)
  • Peach Crumb
  • Lakeshore Berry Crumb (GF)
  • Blueberry Peach Crumb
  • Apple Crumb (GF)
  • Cherry Pie
  • Blueberry Pie
  • Peach Pastry
  • Apple Pie
  • Naturally Apple Pie
  • Pecan
QUICHE 9” only
  • Ham & Cheddar (GF)
  • Broccoli & Cheddar (GF)
  • Spinach, Tomato & Swiss (GF)

Gluten Free

Cookies, Pies & Quiches are available in Gluten Free. 48 hours notice required for Gluten Free orders

*No Sugar Added

STORE HOURS

Mon, Tue, Thurs, Fri -- 6:30 am - 6:00 pm
Sat -- 6:30 am to 3:00 pm
Wed & Sun: Closed

Contact Us

HOLIDAY HOURS

Memorial Day - CLOSED
July 2-5 - CLOSED
Labor Day – CLOSED
12/24 6:30-1:00
12/25-1/8 CLOSED